Skip to system research
Build A Trading SystemRules / Evidence / Replay

Trading-system expectancy after costs

Explore a fixed two-outcome R-multiple example. Inputs are assumptions, not an estimated trading edge.

Original edition: 8 October 2026. Source limits appear below. Expanded edition: 13 October 2026.

Educational research design and invented arithmetic examples. No strategy returns, broker execution or production certification are supplied.

A deliberately simple distribution

Expected R equals win probability times average winning R, minus loss probability times average losing magnitude, minus additional average cost. This assumes only wins and losses, with cost entered separately. If the averages already include that cost, leave the extra cost at zero rather than charging twice.

Not a risk-of-ruin model

The worksheet has no serial dependence, changing risk size, tail events, scratches, capacity or estimation uncertainty. A positive assumed mean is not evidence of a profitable strategy. Its break-even rate only solves the entered two-outcome equation; it does not tell you how many observations establish an edge.

Sources and scope

A fixed arithmetic contract remains

The retained worksheet still uses a two-outcome assumption: entered winner frequency times average winning R, less loser frequency times average losing magnitude and the extra average cost. Its default 45%, 2R, 1R and 0.1R gives gross 0.35R, net 0.25R and conditional break-even about 36.67%. No empirical distribution is supplied. The new synthetic replay does not validate that assumed frequency or payoff. It has its own fixed unit, bars, fill policy and per-side cash fee. The two outputs should not be fused into a claim that the example has a measured edge.

Cost inclusion and invalid states

Extra cost must not already be deducted from the entered averages. A blank, nonfinite, out-of-range frequency, nonpositive payoff magnitude or negative cost clears the record and disables download. A cost large enough to make the conditional break-even exceed 100% is a warning about the assumptions, not a calibrated forecast. Reset restores the invented defaults. The original browser tool neither reads a broker statement nor calculates risk of ruin, serial dependence, changing quantity or an account equity path. Any stronger financial conclusion needs a separate source and policy.

A completed independent arithmetic example

At 45% assumed winner frequency, 0.45 times 2 less 0.55 times 1 gives 0.35R gross. Subtracting the declared additional 0.1R gives 0.25R. The break-even equation is (1 + 0.1) divided by (2 + 1), or about 36.67%. The arithmetic can be independently reproduced while every actual trading observation is absent. Keep that distinction in the JSON export and visible output. Correct formula tests are not additional strategy-validation samples, and a paid provider description cannot turn the assumed numbers into subscriber outcomes.