Skip to system research
Build A Trading SystemRules / Evidence / Replay

The three components a system cannot run without

A task-based reading directory, not a numerical ranking or a representative user survey.

Original edition: 8 October 2026. Source limits appear below. Expanded edition: 13 October 2026.

Educational research design and invented arithmetic examples. No strategy returns, broker execution or production certification are supplied.

Start with an experiment, not a curve

Write down the behaviour you expect, the observations that could contradict it and the market in which the hypothesis applies. Then declare the signal clock, data availability and order lifecycle. A finished-looking equity curve cannot repair an experiment whose decision rules were chosen after seeing its outcome.

Three components still need separate evidence

A testable hypothesis needs an observable counterexample and baseline. A coded exit needs deterministic timing and ownership. A sizing rule needs units, funding context and rounding. The synthetic packet fixes one rule and one time exit with one whole unit, but supplies no market mechanism, personal allocation or broker authority. The original criteria stay useful because a complete mechanics fixture can still fail to answer the economic and account questions. There is no combined assurance score that converts those gaps into a universal financial winner.

A filled criterion record

The example's exit request and simulated fill are reconstructible from bar IDs. Its fixed quantity is also explicit. The appropriate finding is documented synthetic mechanics, not documented economic edge or account suitability. A real review would separately retain the market data, causal objective, complete candidate history and applicable risk policy. A passing source hash does not make those records exist. If only an entry label is supplied, the criterion should name the missing original rule rather than credit a later profitable chart as its counterexample test.

A criterion survives an unresolved result

Use the rule sheet to state the intended decisions, the trace to check implementation and the release workbench to retain operational evidence states. Each can be partially documented without being a certified system. The checksum inspector is another narrow object: it checks file identity, not strategy merit or deployment. A revised exit or funding rule needs a new effective version and authority; it cannot be selected from a viewed holdout and still be reported as frozen earlier. The actual factory/master and production registry remain outside this website's teaching example.